Origin Shorts
Introduction!
- While Peter is in line to enter Oscorp, the student ahead of him looks to be Miles Morales.
- Spencer Smythe is apparently a teacher at Peter's school, and his son, Alistair, is a student.
Observation!
- Peter says that he was bitten by a radioactive spider, and while it makes sense that he can make the connection between Oscorp's escaped spiders and the one that bit him, there's no indication that it's radioactive in any way.
- If this episode is anything to go by, Spider-Man's spider-sense is portrayed as the camera focusing on Peter, while shimmering distortions appear all around him.
- Peter says that "In class, we learned that spiders can lift 173 times their own weight!", but this is untrue. Ants are the species that can lift so much more than themselves; spiders aren't particularly strong for their size.
Hypothesis!
Prediction!
- We get a nice montage of the costumes Peter tries out, and one of them is remarkably similar to the Scarlet Spider's outfit (that is, Ben Reilly's, not Kaine's). Peter comments that it's "too much".
Experimentation!
- Stan Lee makes an appearance as a cameraman on the show, filming Peter before the match.
- The wrestler Peter defeats being named Bonesaw is taken directly from Sam Raimi's first Spider-Man movie - in the comics, the wrestler was named Crusher Hogan.
Conclusion!
- The burglar's gun is this sort of stylised, sci-fi-y thing as opposed to, you know, a gun. I'm not sure whether it's supposed to be setting up some sort of plot, whether it's just stylised, or whether it's some sort of censorship thing and they don't want to or can't show realistic guns. It's explicitly mentioned that it shoots bullets, for what it's worth.
Review: While I think that overall the shorts serve as a nice, non-essential introduction for Spider-Man, and have a good tone, there's one big flaw with them - namely, we don't get to see Uncle Ben, or even Aunt May for that matter, unless you count her voice as an appearance. It's a pretty critical flaw as far as I'm concerned - we need to see how important the two are to Peter, and why exactly the loss of Uncle Ben affects Peter's worldview so much and shapes how he'll use his powers. I don't even think that Uncle Ben is mentioned before he dies; it's almost taken as a given that people will know the story by now, even though the target audience genuinely might not.
There are a few other flaws here too, unfortunately - Peter talking to an old fortuneteller to work out that he should become an entertainer feels like padding, and the third short - Hypothesis! - is almost entirely him mucking around with webs. While it gets better as the shorts go on, Peter's also a bit too nerdy to start off with - when spelling his name out to a guard at Oscorp, he recites, "That's P for phosphorous, E for electron -", which nobody has ever talked like before, ever. I get that we want to emphasise that he's a nerd, and this show looks like it's going to be leaning heavily into the science angle, but that's a bit much.
Still, in spite of all that whinging from me, I did overall enjoy the shorts. The art style is absolutely lovely - I don't know how to describe the colour palette, but it really works for me. Peter going through the scientific method is smart and in character, and for the most part it's pretty light-hearted. It feels like a good, modern update, too - Peter ponders debuting with an internet video, and plenty of citizens video him when he practices his wall-crawling. I wouldn't call it the best origin I've ever seen, but there's enough here to give me some pretty good hope for the show.
No comments:
Post a Comment